The 2016 FR-S is a solid platform built with Subaru's FA20 boxer engine, but it has a well-documented Achilles heel: valve spring failure and catastrophic oil starvation issues under hard use, plus cricket-chirping fuel delivery problems that eventually lead to pump failure.
Valve Spring Failure Leading to Engine Rebuild
Occasional · high severity
Typical onset: 60,000-100,000 mi
Symptoms: Metallic ticking or tapping from engine that increases with RPM, Misfires under load or at high RPM, Check engine light with cylinder misfire codes, Loss of power and rough idle, Metal shavings in oil
Fix: Valve springs fracture and drop into the cylinder, destroying pistons, cylinder walls, and valves. Requires complete engine teardown, often short block replacement or full rebuild with upgraded valve springs. 20-30 hours labor depending on damage extent and parts availability.
Estimated cost: $4,500-8,000
Oil Starvation and Bearing Failure During Spirited Driving
Occasional · high severity
Typical onset: 40,000-80,000 mi
Symptoms: Knocking or rod knock sound during or after hard cornering, Oil pressure warning light during high-G maneuvers, Metallic debris in oil filter, Sudden catastrophic engine failure, Loss of oil pressure at sustained high RPM
Fix: FA20 boxer design causes oil to slosh away from pickup during hard cornering or track use, starving bearings. Spun bearings destroy crankshaft and require complete engine rebuild or replacement. Prevention requires aftermarket oil pan baffle or accusump. Rebuild takes 25-35 hours.
Estimated cost: $5,000-9,000
Fuel Pump Crickets and Premature Failure
Common · medium severity
Typical onset: 50,000-90,000 mi
Symptoms: Cricket chirping sound from rear of car, especially on startup, Hard starting when tank is below 1/4, Rough idle or hesitation under acceleration, Intermittent stalling, Fuel pressure fluctuations
Fix: OEM fuel pump develops loud cricket noise before failing completely. Requires fuel tank drop and pump assembly replacement. TSB issued but many pumps still fail early. 3-4 hours labor for pump replacement.
Estimated cost: $600-1,000
Throwout Bearing (TOB) Chirping and Premature Wear
Common · low severity
Typical onset: 30,000-70,000 mi
Symptoms: Chirping or squealing when clutch pedal is depressed, Grinding noise during shifts, Clutch pedal feel becomes notchy or inconsistent, Noise disappears when clutch is fully engaged
Fix: Factory TOB is inadequately lubricated and wears prematurely, especially with aggressive driving. Requires transmission removal to replace. Smart owners replace clutch assembly at same time since labor is identical. 6-8 hours labor.
Symptoms: Excessive drivetrain clunk during shifts or acceleration, Vibration felt through shifter, Difficulty getting into first or reverse, Shifter movement under throttle, Metallic bang when letting off throttle
Fix: Rubber transmission mount deteriorates from heat and stress, allowing excessive drivetrain movement. Relatively simple replacement but requires lifting powertrain slightly. Many upgrade to polyurethane mounts during replacement. 2-3 hours labor.
Estimated cost: $250-500
Transmission Oil Cooler Line Leaks
Occasional · medium severity
Typical onset: 70,000-120,000 mi
Symptoms: Transmission fluid dripping from front of vehicle, Low transmission fluid level without obvious leak, Transmission overheating during highway driving, Burnt transmission fluid smell, Pink fluid residue on driveway
Fix: Factory crimped cooler lines crack at fittings or develop pin holes from road debris and corrosion. Requires line replacement and fluid refill. Often caught during oil changes. 2-3 hours labor depending on line routing accessibility.
Estimated cost: $400-700
Owner tips
Install an oil pan baffle or accusump system BEFORE any track use or aggressive driving — oil starvation failures happen suddenly and without warning
Check valve spring recall status (TSB EG00216T) and consider upgraded aftermarket springs if doing any engine work
Keep fuel tank above 1/4 to extend fuel pump life and reduce cricket chirping
Change transmission fluid every 30,000 miles with proper GL-4 spec fluid — dealers often use wrong spec
Budget for throwout bearing replacement around 60k if you hear chirping — waiting makes it worse
Inspect transmission cooler lines annually for seepage or corrosion, especially in salt states
Buy one if you understand the valve spring and oil starvation risks and plan to address them preventively — otherwise this is a $5k repair waiting to happen on a car that begs to be driven hard.
AI-assisted summary drawn from NHTSA recall data, our labor-times database, and platform knowledge. Not a substitute for a pre-purchase inspection on a specific vehicle.
Fitment notes: Battery located in trunk; compact size due to trunk placement
As an Amazon Associate, OLP earns from qualifying purchases — how we link. This never changes the specs we publish.
Every control module on the 2013-2016 Toyota Scion FR-S — where it lives, replacement time, and what it takes to program a replacement. Modules marked dealer / factory tool won't work after a part swap alone — budget for programming.
⚠️ Optional equipment; sensor calibration may be needed
Back Monitor Camera ECU (CAMERA ECU)0.5 hr R&Rno coding
📍 Rear cargo area, near liftgate
⚠️ Optional equipment; plug-and-play replacement
Aftermarket tool coverage varies by software version and vehicle build — treat "aftermarket tool" rows as "usually possible" and verify against your tool maker's coverage list before promising a customer. Spot a wrong location or hour? Tell us — corrections ship fast here.
Size-standard part numbers — verify your connector type before buying. Rear blades are model-specific; check the package's vehicle list.
Fuel economy figures are EPA data via fueleconomy.gov (median across matching trims). Performance figures are compiled estimates for the 2016 Toyota Scion FR-S 2.0L H4 and can vary by trim.
🔧 Database maintained under the daily editorial review of Chris Hackleman · Master Technician · 20+ years and Jeff Moore · Master Lexus & Toyota Mechanic · 20+ years.