Engine output, acceleration, top speed, handling, braking — and Nürburgring if either car ran one.
5-Year Maintenance
$33,678
0.56 $/mi
★ WINNER
5-Year Maintenance
$10,022
0.17 $/mi
🏆ADVANTAGEAudi A4 — Saves you $23,656 over 5 years (70% less in routine maintenance labor)
Hours per common service. Lower is faster (and cheaper) at the shop.
1.8T Catastrophic Sludge Failure (Engine Rebuild/Replacement)
Oil & filter change
0.5 hrs$1,380 / 5yr
0.5 hrs$1,380 / 5yr
Tire rotation
0.5 hrs$600 / 5yr
0.5 hrs$600 / 5yr
Rear brake pads
1.2 hrs$500 / 5yr
1.2 hrs$500 / 5yr
Differential fluid
1.3 hrs$470 / 5yr
1.5 hrs$530 / 5yr
Front brake pads
1.0 hrs$460 / 5yr
1.2 hrs$520 / 5yr
Spark plugs
2.5 hrs$455 / 5yr
1.5 hrs$305 / 5yr
Control Arm Bushings and Ball Joints
Timing Belt and Water Pump Failure
Intake manifold gasket
6.5 hrs$320 / 5yr
6.5 hrs$320 / 5yr
Water pump
4.5 hrs$278 / 5yr
4.5 hrs$278 / 5yr
12V battery
0.5 hrs$275 / 5yr
0.5 hrs$275 / 5yr
Brake fluid flush
0.8 hrs$270 / 5yr
0.8 hrs$270 / 5yr
Cabin air filter
0.4 hrs$255 / 5yr
0.4 hrs$255 / 5yr
Wiper blades
0.2 hrs$240 / 5yr
0.2 hrs$240 / 5yr
Valve cover gasket
4.5 hrs$294 / 5yr
2.5 hrs$174 / 5yr
Oxygen sensor
2.0 hrs$210 / 5yr
2.2 hrs$225 / 5yr
Fuel filter
0.5 hrs$210 / 5yr
0.5 hrs$210 / 5yr
Coolant flush
1.2 hrs$230 / 5yr
0.8 hrs$170 / 5yr
Oil pan gasket
4.6 hrs$185 / 5yr
5.2 hrs$208 / 5yr
Automatic Transmission Oil Cooler Line Failure
Alternator
2.5 hrs$169 / 5yr
2.5 hrs$169 / 5yr
Serpentine belt
0.8 hrs$155 / 5yr
0.6 hrs$125 / 5yr
Engine air filter
0.3 hrs$150 / 5yr
0.2 hrs$120 / 5yr
Ignition Coil Pack Failures (1.8T)
Thermostat
2.5 hrs$145 / 5yr
1.8 hrs$109 / 5yr
Power steering flush
0.7 hrs$125 / 5yr
0.7 hrs$125 / 5yr
Starter motor
2.5 hrs$115 / 5yr
2.5 hrs$115 / 5yr
Ignition coil
1.0 hrs$92 / 5yr
1.2 hrs$104 / 5yr
PCV valve
0.5 hrs$95 / 5yr
0.5 hrs$95 / 5yr
Mass Airflow Sensor Contamination (1.8T)
Open NHTSA Recalls
3
3 open
★ WINNER
Open NHTSA Recalls
0
CLEAR
🏆ADVANTAGEAudi A4 — 3 fewer open recalls from the NHTSA
Audi A4
brake · DOT 4 ESP Brake Fluid
coolant10.00 qt · Audi G13 Coolant (Purple)
engine_oil5.50 qt · Castrol Edge 5W-30
front_diff1.50 qt · Audi Differential Fluid
power_steering1.00 qt · Pentosin CHF 11S
rear_diff2.00 qt · Audi Differential Fluid
transfer_case2.50 qt · Audi Transfer Case Fluid
transmission_auto10.00 qt · Audi DSG / S-Tronic Fluid
washer3.50 qt · Windshield Washer Fluid
Audi A4
brake · VW B 000 750
coolant7.50 qt · VW TL 774 J
engine_oil4.50 qt · VW 502.00 / 504.00
front_diff1.50 qt · API GL-5
power_steering · N/A
rear_diff2.00 qt · API GL-5
transfer_case2.50 qt · ATF or manufacturer specific
transmission_auto10.00 qt · ATF for DSG/Tiptronic
washer3.50 qt · All-season or winter-rated
🏆
THE WINNER
2026 Audi A4
2.0L I4 TFSI
- Audi A4 is cheaper to maintain (saves ~$23,656 over 5 years)
- Audi A4 has 3 fewer open NHTSA recalls
Based on objective maintenance and recall data. Driving feel, looks, brand loyalty, and ownership experience are separate (and very valid) considerations.
Open the full dashboard for either truck
Labor times, torque specs, fluid capacities, DTC codes, repair procedures, recalls, common platform problems.